What is a natural birth? The purpose of this page is to answer that question - by sharing all of the advantages and its disadvantages of a natural, low-intervention pregnancy and birth experience - so you can make the best choices for you and your baby.
But before we go any further, please have a look at this picture.
Question: Why is Mama so happy?
Answer: Because she made an important choice about her pregnancy and birth experience. A choice that produced a healthy, active baby, with higher APGAR scores than a typical newborn. A choice that allowed her to recover more quickly than most new moms.
This mother chose a natural childbirth, free from typical hospital interventions, under the expert care of a licensed and experienced midwife. To understand why, let's have a quick visit with Dr. Stuart Fischbein, a board certified OB/GYN and an expert on the midwifery model of care.
Please note: This clip is taken from a longer YouTube video. It will LOOP ENDLESSLY if you allow it to. Just press || pause when you want to move on.
As a licensed midwife with over 25 years of experience attending more than 1500 births, the first thing I want you to know is: the hospital is NOT the only safe option for having your baby.
In fact, studies show that when care is provided by licensed, experienced midwives, the outcomes achieved in non-hospital births are generally better than those achieved in hospitals (Vedam, Stol, MacDorman et al. Journal of Midwifery & Women's Health, 2018)
That said, a hospital birth does have it's place. For some mothers - in particular those with medical complications - it is absolutely the right choice.
But for the vast majority of births, a hospital setting is unnecessarily expensive and physically invasive. Stick with me for awhile and I will show you WHY it's not necessary. More importantly, I will show you alternatives that may work better for you.
The World Health Organization defines natural childbirth as “a process in which a woman delivers vaginally without the use of instruments, epidural anesthesia or general anesthesia.”
While there are many variations of this definition, they all emphasize the general avoidance of medical interventions in what has always been a natural process.
Sometimes people will use the words ‘traditional hospital birth’ or ‘normal hospital birth’ as they try to describe labor and birth options.
Do you know how wrong that is?
The TRUTH is: natural childbirth was a thing long before people started delivering babies in hospitals. In fact, for thousands of years it was the ONLY thing!
So why is it that more than 97% of all births in the United States today occur in hospitals?
Well, that’s a great question. There are some very good reasons to have a hospital birth with standard healthcare providers. But they don’t apply to everybody.
Not even close. Let me explain.
Studies such as Homer, Leap and Edwards et al, "Midwife-led Continuity Models of Care: A Meta-Analysis" (2017) show that for healthy women with low-risk pregnancies, birth outcomes in ‘out of hospital’ (OOH) settings – meaning at home or a stand-alone birthing center – are just as favorable as they are in hospitals. Often much more so.
Statistically speaking, natural childbirth results in:
It’s important to understand, when WE talk about OOH births, we are referring ONLY to healthy, low-risk pregnancies and childbirth under the care of licensed professional midwives.
And when we say ‘healthy, low-risk pregnancies,’ we mean ‘free from a defined set of risk factors identified by medical authorities.’ According to the CDC, 85% of all pregnancies fall into this low-risk category.
Translation: the vast majority of pregnant women are good candidates for natural childbirth.
According to the Medical Board of California, some of the risk factors that call for a hospital-based birth include:
Standards will differ by location. Consult your medical authority for local regulations and guidelines.
Now, with all of that said, let me offer a very powerful perspective on pregnancy and childbirth. As trained, licensed midwives, we know that:
Pregnancy itself is NOT a medical condition.
Childbirth itself is not a medical event.
So then, what is a natural birth? In short, it is birth the way it is supposed to be. Women were having babies for thousands of years before hospitals came along.
Yes, medical doctors can help with pregnancy and childbirth. In some cases they should help. But as we now know, in the vast majority of cases (at least 85% of the time) they are not necessary.
The bottom line is, you were MADE to do this, Mama. You CAN do this. Unless you fall into a higher-risk category you DON’T NEED a hospital.
Even if you do fall into a 'higher' risk category, you should make your preference for minimal intervention known to your doctor (if that is what you want.) They can often make accommodations that would not have been made if you had not asked for them directly.
Let’s take a closer look at what you might expect from each kind of experience (hospital-based birth vs. natural childbirth).
In a Typical Hospital Delivery
In a Typical Home or Birth Center Delivery (Natural Childbirth)
Rules and procedures are enforced by doctors and nurses
Rules and procedures are enforced by doctors and nurses
Pain is managed medically - i.e. via epidural or prescribed medication
Pain management is entirely natural - i.e. breathing / relaxation / waterbirth
Movement is restricted according to equipment and protocol - i.e. beds, stirrups
The mother is free to move and choose her most comfortable position
Family participation is usually restricted and limited to providing moral / spiritual support
No restriction on family involvement. It is not unusual for a family member (or the mother herself) to 'catch' the baby
I could go on and on. But these are some of the key differences.
Now for some new moms, following a specific protocol, being directed by medical doctors, having immediate access to pain relief and emergency intervention if needed is comforting. It feels like the best thing for her and for her baby.
If that is you, wonderful! The hospital will play an important role in your birth process. Find your perfect OB / GYN and work with them to create the birth experience of your dreams. If you have read my bio, you know I have had that experience. Twice :-).
For other new mothers, it is much more important to have their baby, their way. They want to be in control of their entire birth plan. They want to trust their bodies and avoid unnecessary medical interventions. They have a clear answer to the question "what is a natural birth," and they believe that the outcome will be healthier for both mom and baby.
If that is you, wonderful! Find your perfect licensed, experienced midwife and work with them to create the birth experience of your dreams. I’ve had that experience as well. Three times :-).
Which experience did I prefer? You can probably tell by now :-).
If you would like to see my personal reasons why, click over to my article on "10 Advantages of Natural Birth."